January 25, 2026

Launch, Train, Settle: The AI Business of Profitable Infringement

In June 2024, AI music platforms Suno and Udio faced federal lawsuits from the three titans of the industry: Universal Music Group (UMG), Warner Music Group (WMG), and Sony Music Entertainment. The allegation? Massive copyright infringement through unauthorized use of recordings for AI training.

Fast-forward to today, and a pattern has emerged. WMG and UMG have settled with Udio and Suno (late 2025), effectively moving from litigation to partnership.

The Two-Tier Licensing Model

By initially operating without licenses, these companies gained millions of users and developed advanced tech. Now, they are selectively settling only with the players who have the legal power to stop them.

This isn't just a legal victory for labels; it’s a systemic problem. These settlements allow AI companies to continue profiting from past infringement while the independent creators—often the backbone of originality—remain vulnerable.

"The problem is that these settlements encourage companies to use copyrighted material without consent, counting on the fact that they can simply pay a 'settlement fee' once they’ve already become indispensable."

As fair use laws expand, there is a real risk that creative work can be copied without penalty as long as the AI company is "too big to sue."

Want more deep dives into AI ethics?

About William Hodge